Books: Culture



The Smiths: All Men Have Secrets by Tom Gallagher, Michael Campbell, Murdo Gillies. Foreword by John Peel.

Reviewed by Maria Starr



As an avid collector of all things Smiths, I've read my share of books about the band and its front man, Morrissey. When I received this book as a Christmas present this year from my little brother, I was wondering what could be different about this one that I hadn't read about in all my other Smiths books. It turns out the book is quite unique, and one I believe no fan of the band should be without.

All Men Have Secrets is a compilation of short stories, comments and reactions to The Smiths' music, written by fans all over the world. There are tales of standing on the streets of France, bellowing 'Hand in Glove' with college buddies, dancing like a maniac in Essex to 'Bigmouth Strikes Again' and learning to 'Accept Yourself' in Japan after Morrissey asked when you would in the song of the same name. These words could have been written by any of us Smiths devotees - and that is what makes the book so special. Where readers might previously have felt isolated at times in their love for this underappreciated band, now, they can hold in their hands a whole book of stories written by people just like them. I nodded the whole time I read this book, the whole time thinking, "I could have written that", and understanding exactly what these people - strangers from all over the globe - were trying to tell me. If you've ever wondered if others have had the same feelings that you have while listening to these songs, read this book and you will never doubt it again.

I strongly recommend picking it up if you can. It is fascinating, poignant, hilarious in some parts and quite sad in others. I guarantee you will enjoy it, and will want to read it over and over. If you're a Smiths and Morrissey collector like I am, believe me, your collection will not be complete without this masterpiece.